Singleton correctly pointed out that this was a fitness trend that yoga had started in India. Singleton also rightly points out that fitness yoga does not contradict any “spiritual” enterprise of yoga. Feuerstein isn’t arguing that this is the case. He simply points out how modern yoga’s physical exercise lacks a spiritual orientation. This is a critical difference.
Singleton then states that Feuerstein’s claims miss the “deeply spiritual direction of some modern bodybuilding and women’s fitness training in harmonial gymnastics traditions.”
Although I believe I understand what Feuerstein meant by “deeply Spiritual”, I still don’t know what Singleton meant by it, despite reading Yoga Body. This makes intelligent comparisons difficult. This is why Singleton brought it up in his closing arguments in a book about physical postures. It is clear that Singleton has a point. If you suffering from erectile dysfunction or impotence issues so buy Silagra 100 which is used to treat erectile dysfunction or premature ejaculation for men age between 18 to 65 years.
He did make some point, so I’d like to reply.
Feuerstein says that yoga’s goal is to achieve enlightenment (Samadhi), and not physical or spiritual fitness. A slimmer, healthier body is not the goal of yoga, but it will increase your chances of spiritual liberation.
Yoga is for him primarily a spiritual practice that involves deep postures, deep studies, and deep meditation. Although postures are an integral part traditional yoga, it is possible to attain enlightenment even without practicing posture yoga. This has been indisputably demonstrated by such sages like Ananda Mai Ma and Ramana Maharishi and Nisargadatta Maharaj.
From the perspective of traditional yoga, the bigger question is: Is it possible to achieve enlightenment solely through the practice and enjoyment of yoga? It is not possible. It is unlikely. It is not possible to practice the type of fitness yoga Singleton claims to be spiritual.
Integral yoga says that the body is the outermost layer of the mind. However, enlightenment takes place beyond the fifth and most innermost layers of the subtle body (or kosa), and not in the body. This is why fitness yoga has limitations from the perspective of yoga. It cannot deliver the desired results on its own.
Feuerstein, and all of us traditionalists (oh! those darn labels!) are similar. We are simply saying that fitness yoga won’t work if your goal it enlightenment. It’s possible to do power yoga all day, but it won’t make you enlightened. cenforce 150 is Cure Erectile Dysfunction Problems in men. It start working in about 30 minutes and for up to 4 hours. The drug contains Sildenafil as the active ingredient. Do not eat the medicine with any fruit juices or alcohol.
They created sitting yoga poses (padmasana siddhasana viirasana etc.) to serve this purpose. They spent more time in meditation than they did moving around, because it was sitting postures that induced the desired state of enlightenment or Samadhi.
You can also be enlightened even if you don’t practice the various hatha poses, but it is unlikely that you will become spiritually enlightened just by practicing these postures.
These are the layers and perspectives that Yoga Body was missing. Feuerstein’s criticism seems shallow and kneejerk.
Singleton’s focus on the history and physical practice of modern yoga is thorough, accurate and impressive. However, his insistent that modern gymnastics and posture pose yoga have “deeply spiritual” aspects misses an important aspect of yoga. Specifically, that our bodies can only be as spiritual as our hearts are.